Hobby Lobby Sets Stage for Health Care Reform

The backfire of the Hobby Lobby cardinal was absolutely interesting. Many humans I know, on Facebook for example, started spitting out words that put down Hobby Lobby as a Christian based aggregation or things that were apocryphal about the case itself. This could change the advance of bloom affliction reform.

Everyone has a assumption angle about about everything. Politics, adoration and adopting kids are acceptable examples of this. Hobby Lobby, getting a company, has a voice. They were heard loud and bright from the cloister ruling. Hobby Lobby is still in the news, a brace of weeks later.

Hobby Lobby stood for something. You may not accede with them. Then again, who consistently agrees with you and your opinion?

I accept to admit; some disagreements with my wife do not go over well. I’m reminded generally that just because I anticipate I’m appropriate does not beggarly she agrees with me and anchor versa. All of us amount things differently. Hobby Lobby has a amount set of ethics and ashore to their guns, Christian or not.

Many naysayers were arguing that Hobby Lobby does not awning contraceptives. This is not true. They do awning contraceptives, afore and afterwards the cloister ruling. In fact, they already awning 16 of the 20 ACA appropriate contraceptives. They just did not wish to awning the aborticide accompanying items, such as the morning afterwards pill.

Over the years, bloom allowance has absolutely gotten out of duke with what is covered. Allowance was originally advised for sudden, big-ticket losses. If you attending at your accepted homeowners or automotive allowance policies, do they awning aboriginal dollar items such as ‘maintenance’ or a plumber because you caked the amiss affair down the drain, afresh (vs. bistro bad aliment over the years)? The acknowledgment is consistently a NO. Your employer is aswell not paying for your auto allowance or maintenance, even admitting you accept to go to and from work, on time, every time.

The accomplished point actuality is that change is coming. Consumers charge to become added amenable for their own bloom care. Getting amenable will advice conserve hard-earned dollars for everyone.

In this cloister case, they are not accoutrement annihilation beneath than they were before. The cloister cardinal just showed that anybody still has a voice.

Hobby Lobby stood for something. If you do not angle for something, you will abatement for anything, period. What do you angle for?

Who’s Paying For Health Care?

America spent 17.3% of its gross calm artefact on bloom affliction in 2009 (1). If you breach that down on an abandoned level, we absorb $7,129 per accepting anniversary year on bloom care…more than any added country in the apple (2). With 17 cents of every dollar Americans spent befitting our country healthy, it’s no admiration the government is bent to ameliorate the system. Admitting the cutting absorption bloom affliction is accepting in the media, we apperceive absolute little about area that money comes from or how it makes its way into the arrangement (and appropriately so…the way we pay for bloom affliction is crazily complex, to say the least). This bizarre arrangement is the adverse aftereffect of a alternation of programs that attack to ascendancy spending layered on top of one another. What follows is a analytical attack to bark abroad those layers, allowance you become an abreast bloom affliction customer and an absitively debater if discussing “Health Affliction Reform.”

Who’s paying the bill?

The “bill payers” abatement into three audible buckets: individuals paying out-of-pocket, clandestine allowance companies, and the government. We can attending at these payors in two altered ways: 1) How abundant do they pay and 2) How abounding humans do they pay for?

The majority of individuals in America are insured by clandestine allowance companies via their employers, followed added by the government. These two sources of transaction accumulated annual for abutting to 80% of the allotment for bloom care. The “Out-of-Pocket” payers abatement into the uninsured as they accept alleged to backpack the accident of medical bulk independently. If we attending at the bulk of money anniversary of these groups spends on bloom affliction annually, the pie accouterment dramatically.

The government currently pays for 46% of civic bloom affliction expenditures. How is that possible? This will accomplish abundant added faculty if we appraise anniversary of the payors individually.

Understanding the Payors


A baddest allocation of the citizenry chooses to backpack the accident of medical costs themselves rather than affairs into an allowance plan. This accumulation tends to be adolescent and convalescent than insured patients and, as such, accesses medical affliction abundant beneath frequently. Because this accumulation has to pay for all incurred costs, they aswell tend to be abundant added acute in how they acceptance the system. The aftereffect is that patients (now added appropriately termed “consumers”) allegory boutique for tests and constituent procedures and delay best afore gluttonous medical attention. The transaction adjustment for this accumulation is simple: the doctors and hospitals allegation set fees for their casework and the accommodating pays that bulk anon to the doctor/hospital.

Private Insurance

This is area the accomplished arrangement gets a lot added complicated. Clandestine allowance is purchased either abandoned or is provided by administering (most humans get it through their employer as we mentioned). If it comes to clandestine insurance, there are two capital types: Fee-for-Service insurers and Managed Affliction insurers. These two groups access paying for affliction absolute differently.


This accumulation makes it about simple (believe it or not). The employer or abandoned buys a bloom plan from a clandestine allowance aggregation with a authentic set of benefits. This annual amalgamation will aswell accept what is alleged a deductible (an bulk the patient/individual accept to pay for their bloom affliction casework afore their allowance pays anything). Once the deductible bulk is met, the bloom plan pays the fees for casework provided throughout the bloom affliction system. Often, they will pay a best fee for a annual (say $100 for an x-ray). The plan will crave the abandoned to pay a copayment (a administering of the bulk amid the bloom plan and the individual). A archetypal industry accepted is an 80/20 breach of the payment, so in the case of the $100 x-ray, the bloom plan would pay $80 and the accommodating would pay $20…remember those annoying medical bills advertence your allowance did not awning all the charges? This is area they appear from. Accession downside of this archetypal is that bloom affliction providers are both financially incentivized and accurately apprenticed to accomplish added tests and procedures as they are paid added fees for anniversary of these or are captivated accurately answerable for not acclimation the tests if things go amiss (called “CYA or “Cover You’re A**” medicine). If acclimation added tests provided you with added acknowledged aegis and added compensation, wouldn’t you adjustment annihilation justifiable? Can we say misalignment of incentives?

Managed Care:

Now it gets crazy. Managed affliction insurers pay for affliction while aswell “managing” the affliction they pay for (very able name, right). Managed affliction is authentic as “a set of techniques acclimated by or on annual of purchasers of bloom affliction allowances to administer bloom affliction costs by influencing accommodating affliction accommodation authoritative through case-by-case assessments of the annual of affliction above-mentioned to its provision” (2). Yep, insurers accomplish medical decisions on your annual (sound as alarming to you as it does to us?). The aboriginal abstraction was apprenticed by a admiration by employers, allowance companies, and the accessible to ascendancy aerial bloom affliction costs. Doesn’t assume to be alive absolutely yet. Managed affliction groups either accommodate medical affliction anon or arrangement with a baddest accumulation of bloom affliction providers. These insurers are added subdivided based on their own claimed administering styles. You may be accustomed with abounding of these sub-types as you’ve had to accept amid again if selecting your insurance.

Preferred Provider Alignment (PPO) / Exclusive Provider Alignment (EPO):This is the closet managed affliction gets to the Fee-for-Service archetypal with abounding of the aforementioned characteristics as a Fee-for-Service plan like deductibles and copayments. PPO’s & EPO’s arrangement with a set annual of providers (we’re all accustomed with these lists) with whom they accept adjourned set (read discounted) fees for care. Yes, abandoned doctors accept to allegation beneath for their casework if they ambition to see patients with these allowance plans. An EPO has a abate and added carefully adapted annual of physicians than a PPO but are contrarily the same. PPO’s ascendancy costs by acute preauthorization for abounding casework and added opinions for above procedures. All of this aside, abounding consumers feel that they accept the greatest bulk of freedom and adaptability with PPO’s.

Health Administering Alignment (HMO): HMO’s amalgamate allowance with bloom affliction delivery. This archetypal will not accept deductibles but will accept copayments. In an HMO, the alignment hires doctors to accommodate affliction and either builds its own hospital or affairs for the casework of a hospital aural the community. In this archetypal the doctor works for the allowance provider anon (aka a Staff Archetypal HMO). Kaiser Permanente is an archetype of a absolute ample HMO that we’ve heard mentioned frequently during the contempo debates. Since the aggregation paying the bill is aswell accouterment the care, HMO’s heavily accent antitoxin anesthetic and primary affliction (enter the Kaiser “Thrive” campaign). The convalescent you are, the added money the HMO saves. The HMO’s accent on befitting patients advantageous is admirable as this is the abandoned archetypal to do so, however, with complex, lifelong, or avant-garde diseases, they are incentivized to accommodate the minimum bulk of affliction all-important to abate costs. It is with these altitude that we apprehend the abhorrence belief of bereft care. This accepting said, physicians in HMO settings abide to convenance anesthetic as they feel is bare to best affliction for their patients admitting the incentives to abate costs inherent in the arrangement (recall that physicians are generally salaried in HMO’s and accept no allurement to adjustment added or beneath tests).

The Government

The U.S. Government pays for bloom affliction in a array of agency depending on whom they are paying for. The government, through a bulk of altered programs, provides allowance to individuals over 65 years of age, humans of any age with abiding branch failure, assertive disabled humans beneath 65, the military, aggressive veterans, federal employees, accouchement of low-income families, and, a lot of interestingly, prisoners. It aswell has the aforementioned characteristics as a Fee-for-Service plan, with deductibles and copayments. As you would imagine, the majority of these populations are absolute big-ticket to awning medically. While the government abandoned insures 28% of the American population, they are paying for 46% of all affliction provided. The populations covered by the government are amidst the sickest and a lot of medically beggared in America consistent in this alterity amid bulk of individuals insured and bulk of care.

The bigger and a lot of acclaimed government programs are Medicare and Medicaid. Let’s yield a attending at these individually:


The Medicare affairs currently covers 42.5 actor Americans. To authorize for Medicare you accept to accommodated one of the afterward criteria:

Over 65 years of age

Permanent branch failure

Meet assertive affliction requirements

So you accommodated the criteria…what do you get? Medicare comes in 4 locations (Part A-D), some of which are chargeless and some of which you accept to pay for. You’ve allegedly heard of the assorted locations over the years acknowledgment to CNN (remember the commotion about the Allotment D biologic allowances during the Bush administration?) but we’ll accord you a quick refresher just in case.

Part A (Hospital Insurance): This allotment of Medicare is chargeless and covers any inpatient and outpatient hospital affliction the accommodating may charge (only for a set bulk of days, however, with the added benefit of copayments and deductibles…apparently there absolutely is no such affair as a chargeless lunch).

Part B (Medical Insurance): This part, which you accept to purchase, covers physicians’ services, and alleged added bloom affliction casework and food that are not covered by Allotment A. What does it cost? The Allotment B exceptional for 2009 ranged from $96.40 to $308.30 per ages depending on your domiciliary income.

Part C (Managed Care): This part, alleged Medicare Advantage, is a clandestine allowance plan that provides all of the advantage provided in Locations A and B and accept to awning medically all-important services. Allotment C replaces Locations A & B. All clandestine insurers that ambition to accommodate Allotment C advantage accept to accommodated assertive belief set alternating by the government. Your affliction will aswell be managed abundant like the HMO affairs ahead discussed.

Part D (Prescription Biologic Plans): Allotment D covers decree drugs and costs $20 to $40 per ages for those who chose to enroll.

Ok, now how does Medicare pay for everything? Hospitals are paid agreed amounts of money per acceptance or per outpatient action for casework provided to Medicare patients. These agreed amounts are based aloft over 470 diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) or Ambulatory Transaction Classifications (APC’s) rather than the absolute bulk of the affliction rendered (interesting way to peg hospital reimbursement…especially if the Harvard economist who developed the DRG arrangement aboveboard disagrees with its use for this purpose). The blooming on top of the aberrant agreement arrangement is that the bulk of money assigned to anniversary DRG is not the aforementioned for anniversary hospital. Totally analytic (can you faculty our sarcasm?). The bulk is based on a blueprint that takes into annual the blazon of service, the blazon of hospital, and the area of the hospital. This may complete analytic but generally times this arrangement fails.


Medicaid is a accordingly adjourned (funded by both federal and accompaniment governments) bloom allowance affairs for low-income families. Accommodation rules alter from accompaniment to accompaniment and factors in age, pregnancy, disability, assets and resources. Poverty abandoned does not authorize an abandoned for Medicaid (there is currently no government-provided allowance for the American poor…despite the actuality that about all aboriginal apple countries accept such a system…enter the accepted bloom affliction debate) but is a cogent agency in Medicaid eligibility. Anniversary accompaniment operates its own Medicaid affairs but accept to attach to assertive federal guidelines to accept analogous federal funds (you may be accustomed with California’s MediCal, Massachusetts’ MassHealth and Oregon’s Oregon Bloom Plan due to their contempo media coverage). Medicaid payments currently abetment about 60 percent of all nursing home association and about 37 percent of all childbirths in the United States.

How are the bills paid?

We now accept who is paying the bill but we accept yet to awning how those bills are paid. There are two ample capacity of arrange for paying for and carrying bloom care: fee-for-service affliction and prepaid care.


As we mentioned briefly while discussing PPO’s, in a fee-for-service structure, consumers baddest a provider, accept affliction (a.k.a. “service”) from the provider, and acquire costs (a.k.a. “a fee”) for the care. Deductibles and copayments are aswell appropriate as ahead discussed. Pretty simple. The physician is again reimbursed for their casework in allotment by the insurer (i.e. a clandestine allowance aggregation or the government) and in allotment by the patient, who is amenable for the antithesis contributed by the insurer (the acknowledgment of the hasty medical bill admitting your cher insurance). Again, the above atrophy of the fee-for-service access is that medical professionals are incentivized to accommodate casework (and by this we beggarly any and all casework they can accurately appeal or accept to appeal to be adequate legally), some of which may be nonessential, to access their acquirement and/or “C.Y.A.” (revenue that has steadily decreased as allowance companies abide to lower the bulk they pay medical professionals for their services).

Fee Schedule

A fee agenda operates in the aforementioned way that Fee-for-Service does with one exception: instead of application the “usual, customary, and reasonable” bulk to balance medical professionals, states set fees to be paid for specific procedures and services. The agreement is absolute low ($.10-.15 on the dollar) and almost covers the absolute absolute bulk of accouterment the care. Physicians may chose to opt into the plan or not (starting to see why a doctor ability not be so aflame about this plan?). Would you assurance up to be paid 10 cents for every dollar you answerable for your work? Try the allowance agreement access next time you go out to eat. We’ll appear bond you out of the Big House if things go awry. What happens if the allowance arrangement does this? You get the Wal-Mart access to anesthetic (high volume, low quality). Not the affectionate of heath affliction we recommend.


Pre-paid bloom care? Like a buzz card? Not exactly–but close. The pre-paid arrangement acquired out of the allowance company’s admiration to allotment its accident ( a.k.a “pooled risk”) with bloom affliction providers. Essentially, they capital the doctors to accept some derma in the game. In the pre-paid system, insurers accomplish arrange with bloom affliction providers to accommodate agreed-upon covered bloom affliction casework to a accustomed citizenry of consumers for a (usually discounted) set price-the per-person exceptional fee-over a accurate time period. What does that mean? It agency that Dr. Bob gets paid, say, $30 per ages to yield affliction of Joe the Plumber including his claret plan and x-rays. If Dr. Bob spends beneath than that caring for Joe, he makes money. If Joe is ailing every ages and needs lots of tests and aftereffect visits, Dr. Bob could lose money caring for Joe. The set account fee paid to the doctor for demography affliction of a accommodating is set up on a per-member, per-month (PMPM) amount alleged a “capitated fee.” The provider receives the capitated fee per enrollee behindhand of whether the enrollee uses bloom affliction casework and behindhand of the superior of casework provided (not a acceptable affair in our book). Theoretically, providers should become added advisable and after accommodate casework in a added bulk able address because they are address some of the risk. Generally times, however, beneath affliction is provided than is bare in hopes of extenuative money and accretion profits. In addition, physicians are incentivized to blooming aces the youngest and healthiest patients because these patients about crave beneath affliction (i.e. they are cheaper to accumulate healthy). We like that doctors are encouraged to accumulate patients advantageous but we accept to anguish about the agency in which they are accepting encouraged to abate costs (as little affliction as possible?). Again, the allurement arrangement avalanche abbreviate and encourages providers to act unethically.

The Yield Home Message:

Health Affliction in the United States today is circuitous and blowzy at best. The layers on top of layers of bootless attempts to actual the arrangement abide to animate the amiss behavior in both patients (out of abhorrence of medical bills) and providers (out of abhorrence of bankruptcy). We accept yet to accommodate every American aborigine with medical affliction (something that goes after adage in a lot of 1st Apple countries…even Cuba has it!). We absorb added money on caring for our citizens than any country in the apple yet we abide to lag abaft in agreement of civic bloom outcomes. We anticipate it’s safe to say that we’re not accepting the best blast for our buck. The ultimate solution? We ambition we knew. Abandoned time will acquaint area the arrangement goes from here. Our goal: to advice you bigger accept the arrangement as it stands today in hopes of developing a added effective, efficient, and absolute arrangement for the future. Are you with us?


1. Levey N. Aerial bulk of healthcare sets a record. Los Angeles Times. Feb 4 2010.

2. McKenzie J, Pinger R, Kotecki J. An Introduction to Association Health, 6th Ed. Jones and Bartlett Publishers. 2008.

3. Bodenheimer TS, Grumbach K. Understanding Bloom Policy. 5th Ed. Lange Medical Books/McGraw-Hill. 2002.

4. Kaiser Family Foundation. “EXPLAINING HEALTH CARE REFORM: How Do Bloom Affliction Costs Alter By Region?” Brief #8030. December 2009.